Need help figuring out adoption relationships? Schedule a complimentary consultation with Lori Holden, M.A.
patricia florin closed adoption

Book Review: Patricia Florin’s “A Life Let Go”

I’ll cut to the chase: I loved this book.

Months ago author Patricia Florin sent me A Life Let Go to review. I had a big stack of books in my queue and not enough reading time to get to hers in a gracious manner, but I finally got time to read during our recent trip to Ireland.

Could Not Put it Down

While traveling I read A Life Let Go on flights and on car rides. I read while standing in lines and at bedtime. Not because it’s an easy read; it’s a tough read for the pain in it. But resilience shines through as well. It’s affirming to watch broken people find ways to become whole again.

If you’ve ever wondered how someone can “give up” their baby for adoption, order this book. The stories in it explain what having an unplanned pregnancy and closed adoption were like during the Baby Scoop Era when, due to shame (for the baby having the bad fortune to be conceived accidentally, for a woman in an oops pregnancy,  for couples unlucky  to not be able to make babies), things had to be hidden.

6 Stories

A Life Let Go has six sections. The first is Patricia’s own story of an unplanned pregnancy in the 1970s. During the last few months of her pregnancy she is forced to hide in the upper floor of her parents’ home, lest her situation bring shame to the family.

The other five stories Patricia collected from women she met in her efforts as a community builder for this hidden population. Each story speaks to the devastation that resulted from the closed adoption practices of the shame-based era.

  • Nancy was anxious to do the right thing in 1983
  • Evelyn learns her husband isn’t ready to be a father in 1964.
  • Marti is unable to parent a third child in 1959.
  • Dena marries the abusive father in 1969, which is unsustainable.
  • Kate and her supportive parents navigate the social work system in 1969.

Closedness Breeds Brittleness in Adoptive Parents

Evelyn, mentioned above, had placed two children a few years apart and in different families. She eventually found both when they were adults. Reunion went smoothly with her son, Philip, but not so much with her daughter, Julia. Closedness had made Julia’s adoptive mother brittle, unable to shift from an Either/Or mindset to a Both/And heartset.  Excerpt:

Julia had told her mother about my finding her, and her mother was unsure about it. I wrote Julia’s mother a letter to show I was supportive of her relationship with Julia, not a threat.  I got a letter back saying “Julia is our child and you have broken confidentiality by contacting us. Please don’t ever contact me again.”

I haven’t communicated with her since.

Because her adoptive mother doesn’t approve of my finding Julia, Julia feels disloyal when she contacts me, so I leave it open with her. I let Julia initiate and direct all our communication. When I do get to talk with her, it’s like we were never apart.

Kudos to Patricia Florin for putting together a book that helps readers understand the predicament, the non-choice, that so many women in the 1950s-1980s faced when they found themselves unexpectedly pregnant. Thanks to Patricia and her contributors for highlighting the ongoing burden that the closed, shame-based system placed on everyone involved in adoption — including adoptive parents like me.

Click for more AdoptLit.

Lori Holden, mom of a young adult daughter and a young adult son, writes from Denver. She was honored as an Angel in Adoption® by the Congressional Coalition on Adoption Institute.

Find Lori’s books on her Amazon Author page, and catch episodes of Adoption: The Long View wherever you get your podcasts.

New Posts Delivered to You

6 Responses

  1. That book sounds amazing. I feel like there is a distinct lack of empathy for birth parents, especially when talking about adoption with older people (by older I mean 50+, and older than me, not “old”). There’s a lot of “I could NEVER give up my baby” or “How can these women do it?” without any sense of “How hard must that be?” or even just “I wonder what it would feel like to be in that situation of making a choice, or having it made for you due to social norms and/or family pressure at the time.” I love stories and books that breed empathy, and this sounds like a good one! Thanks for sharing.

  2. It sounds like a fascinating book; one that adoptive parents would want to read to understand the world from new angles.

  3. Thanks for sharing, Lori! I just checked and realized our public library doesn’t even have a copy. Looks like I’ll have to purchase it and (after reading it) donate it. These stories need to be heard. I’m looking forward to hearing them in greater detail.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New Posts Delivered to You

Be the first to know about each new post. 

(Just a few each month.)